San Andres vs Providencia: Which Caribbean Island to Pick?
San Andres and Providencia are Colombian islands 720 km north of the mainland, closer to Nicaragua than to Colombia. The sea of seven colors is the main attraction. This guide compares the two so you can decide which one or whether to do both.
Quick Answer: Choose San Andres for direct flights, more hotels, nightlife and snorkeling at Johnny Cay. Choose Providencia for untouched beaches, no crowds and the world second largest barrier reef. Ideally do both if you have 5+ days.
San Andres at a glance
Direct flights from Bogota, Medellin and Cartagena
Catalina Airlines flies daily from San Andres to Providencia (20 minutes, $150-250 USD round trip). There is also a catamaran (3 hours, 220,000 COP) but it is often rough and cancelled.
Providencia has less developed, whiter sand beaches (Manzanillo, South West Bay). San Andres has busier beaches with more amenities (Sound Bay, Johnny Cay).
Mid-range. Hotels: $50-200 USD. Restaurants: $15-30 USD. Airport tax for tourists: 120,000 COP ($30 USD) paid on arrival.
